
Mystery Subscription Box
Regular price $42.00
Mystery Cookie Subscription Box (3-Month Plan)
A Sweet Experience, Month After Month
Whether you are treating yourself or gifting someone special, our Mystery Cookie Subscription Box provides a rotating selection of handcrafted flavors, thoughtfully packaged and baked from scratch. Let us surprise you with something unforgettable each month.
No Refunds • No Early Cancellations
Enjoy three months of freshly baked goodness with our Mystery Cookie Subscription Box. Once you sign up, your subscription is locked in for the full three-month duration, and early cancellation is not permitted. All subscription sales are final and non-refundable.
Each month, you will receive:
- One dozen cookies featuring four different flavors
- A curated mix of our most popular specialty and traditional varieties
- Individually bagged cookies for freshness and convenience
Every box offers a unique assortment, making each month a delicious surprise.
Delivery and Pickup Options
We do not currently ship through the mail, but we offer two convenient options for receiving your subscription box:
Local Delivery – $10 per delivery
Delivery is completed by our company vehicle. We offer delivery throughout Cincinnati and as far South as Florence, Kentucky. You will be invoiced for delivery each month 2 days before your scheduled delivery. After placing your order, you will receive a list of available delivery dates for your first delivery and times to choose from. All delivery options provided will be no earlier than at least one week from the date your subscription is placed.
For future months, a confirmation email will be sent with delivery dates and times available and verification of the preferred delivery address. The delivery invoice must be paid prior to each delivery time or the monthly subscription will need to be picked up instead.
Free Store Pickup
Pickup is available at no additional cost during our storefront operating hours (Fridays 2-7, Saturdays 12-6). If you select the pickup option, your first order will be ready the following Friday or Saturday (which ever day works best). For future months, an email will be sent to determine your availability for pickups each month.